Pay-Per-Click advertising would be a great way to start generating interest in your business. It can be geo-targeted so you only reach specific regions (may help with your shipping costs) and you can set a budget you're comfortable with.
PPC can be very time consuming, but if you start small it can be very manageable and effective. Maybe start with two AdGroups of 5 keywords each, and see how it goes.
I'd recommend starting with Google AdWords - https://adwords.google.com - this is the most intuitive of the PPC bidding engines. Plus Google offers great training and help modules for when you're just starting out.
Another great way to drive traffic to your site would be through social networking. I did a few searches for "chocoholics" and "chocolate discussions" and found a few networking sites where you might want to become an active member, and even post some pictures of your work.
http://www.smallerindiana.com/group/chocolateloversgroup
http://www.virb.com/groups/73511233
http://flickr.com/groups/66035042@N00/discuss/
Megan Hauer
Director, Digital Media & Content
Optiem
216-574-8700