written on July 01, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
Related Items
- Expanding Ban the Box Legislation Impacts Small Business
-
written on March 01, 2012
by Ted L Moss
- Pre Employment vs. Post Employment Investigations
-
written on October 27, 2011
by Ted L Moss
- How do I identify good people and get them OnBoard?
-
written on October 13, 2011
by Steve Krisfalusy
- Onboarding and a Whole Lot More
-
written on September 20, 2011
by Steve Krisfalusy
- Avoid Hiring Mistakes. Hire Right. It’s as Easy as Riding a B.i.k.e
-
written on June 23, 2011
by Shelley Solomon Cull
- Vetting your C-Level Management Part 2: Federal Criminal Records and Credit Reports
-
written on April 15, 2011
by Ted L Moss
- Designing Your Management Team - Vetting your C-Level Management Foundation
-
written on January 21, 2011
by Ted L Moss
- How a Little Creativity Can Bring Big Rewards in Recruiting
-
written on November 19, 2010
by Kenyon Mau
- Tips on How to Hire Your First Employee
-
written on November 17, 2010
by Joe Mayer
- Hiring Your First Employee
-
written on November 12, 2010
by Steve Krisfalusy
- The Use of Public and Private Records for Pre-Employment Screening
-
written on November 03, 2010
by Ted L Moss
- Five Tips to Avoid Resume Fraud
-
written on September 07, 2010
by Ted L Moss
- Social Networks as a Pre-Employment Screening Tool
-
written on July 09, 2010
by Ted L Moss
- Hiring the Right Person is the First Step in the Talent Management Process
-
written on August 12, 2009
by Ted L Moss
- Multiple Indepth References are Critical to the Hiring Process
-
written on July 22, 2009
by Laurie Mitchell
- Should You Consider Using Outplacment Services
-
written on May 07, 2009
by Ginni Garner
- Leading Brand or Metoo Product
-
written on April 30, 2009
by Ginni Garner
- Fingerprint Based Criminal Record Searches
-
written on April 16, 2009
by Ted L Moss
- Top Ten Trends in the Screening Industry
-
written on April 14, 2009
by Ginni Garner
- Sourcing in 2009 Great Resources for Finding Talent Online
-
written on April 01, 2009
by Ginni Garner
- Free Public Records So You Want To Do Your Own Background Checks
-
written on March 17, 2009
by Ted L Moss
- Actions Managers Can Do During This Recession to Retain Employees for Later
-
written on March 11, 2009
by Kenyon Mau
- Whats Leadership Got to Do With Retention
-
written on February 20, 2009
by Kenyon Mau
- Are You Closing the Deal
-
written on February 18, 2009
by Ginni Garner
- Recruiting Good People
-
written on January 26, 2009
by Steve Krisfalusy
- Is It As Bad As They Say
-
written on January 21, 2009
by Kenyon Mau
- 15 Onboarding Errors Companies Make Part 2 of 2 Part Series
-
written on December 18, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- 15 Onboarding Errors Companies Make Part 1 of a 2Part Series
-
written on December 02, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- My Lips are Sealed Employment Job Reference Checks and Shield Laws
-
written on November 18, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- Integrity How Can I Interview for It
-
written on October 28, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Drug Testing for Small Businesses
-
written on September 29, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- Can the Talk of Politics Survive in an Office During an Election Year
-
written on September 18, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- How a Phone Can Increase Your Recruiting Effectiveness
-
written on September 09, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Employee Retention in Practice
-
written on August 18, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Credit Screening for preemployment purposes
-
written on July 31, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- The Importance of Onboarding New Employees
-
written on July 28, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Lous Law How a Little Creativity Can Bring Big Rewards in Recruiting
-
written on June 24, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Before Posting an Open Job
-
written on June 03, 2008
by Kenyon Mau
- Why Review an Applicants Driving Record
-
written on May 19, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- A Criminal Records Primer for the Employer
-
written on April 17, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- Finding a Reputable Preemployment Screening Provider
-
written on April 17, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- Outsourcing Cost Savings or Risky Business
-
written on April 02, 2008
by Ted L Moss
- Negligent Hiring What Every Employer Needs to Know
-
written on March 27, 2008
by Ted L Moss
View All
More By This Expert
-
Employees Matter Too!
-
written on April 11, 2011 by Kenyon Mau
-
Card Check is Still Alive
-
written on March 22, 2011 by Kenyon Mau
-
The Widening Gap
-
written on February 22, 2011 by Kenyon Mau
-
Keep an Eye on Employee Free Choice EFCA in 2011
-
written on December 28, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
-
How a Little Creativity Can Bring Big Rewards in Recruiting
-
written on November 19, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
-
To Some This Rule is Golden
-
written on September 02, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
-
Not Out of the Woods on EFCA Just Yet
-
written on July 29, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
-
Employee Free Choice Act
-
written on June 07, 2010 by Kenyon Mau
-
The Burden of Clarity
-
written on October 12, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Specter Nows Adds Name to EFCA Proponents
-
written on October 06, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
How Knowing What Energizes Your Employees Will Help You
-
written on August 27, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
A Matter of Trust
-
written on August 12, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Recruiting Strategies to Keep You Pro-Employee
-
written on July 16, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
How Do We Remedy Sinking Morale After Layoffs?
-
written on July 06, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
The Costs of Not Being Pro-Employee
-
written on June 23, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
What is the Employee Free Choice Act and How Would It Impact You?
-
written on May 29, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Assessing Employee Engagement Without Breaking the Bank (Part 2 of 2)
-
written on May 06, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Assessing Employee Engagement Without Breaking the Bank (Part 1 or 2)
-
written on April 15, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Actions Managers Can Do During This Recession to Retain Employees for Later
-
written on March 11, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
What's Leadership Got to Do With Retention?
-
written on February 20, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
Is It As Bad As They Say?
-
written on January 21, 2009 by Kenyon Mau
-
15 On-boarding Errors Companies Make (Part 2 of 2 Part Series)
-
written on December 18, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
15 On-boarding Errors Companies Make (Part 1 of a 2-Part Series)
-
written on December 02, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
Integrity: How Can I Interview for It?
-
written on October 28, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
Can the Talk of Politics Survive in an Office During an Election Year?
-
written on September 18, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
How a Phone Can Increase Your Recruiting Effectiveness
-
written on September 09, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
Employee Retention in Practice
-
written on August 18, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
The Importance of Onboarding New Employees
-
written on July 28, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
Lou's Law - How a Little Creativity Can Bring Big Rewards in Recruiting
-
written on June 24, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
-
Before Posting an Open Job
-
written on June 03, 2008 by Kenyon Mau
View All
I came across this article by John Hollon a contributing writer to the recruiting web site www.ere.net. As a former editor with Workforce Magazine, he has an interesting twist on recruiting: more Simon and less Paula Abdula and American Idol as a metaphor for recruiting.
At its core, American Idol is all about finding and promoting the very best talent — something that HR leaders do for their organizations every single day. But, how the show ultimately goes about finding and promoting the best talent leaves a lot to be desired, and it raises some issues that every HR person should think about in their own talent development process.
So, here are three talent management takeaways I gleaned from American Idol:
The highly-competent-but-safe candidate doesn’t always make the best hire:
Are you satisfied choosing someone who is “safe” and won’t get you into trouble, or, do you go with the flashier choice who may have not only more upside, but perhaps some downside too? This year’s Idol runner-up, Crystal Bowersox, has over-the-top talent and style to burn, but she’s also is a single mom with dreadlocks and numerous tattoos who doesn’t really “look” the part of an American Idol. People like her can make you look really good, but, not everyone else may agree.
This points to an management truism worth remembering: safe but unexciting choices yield safe but unexciting results. If that’s what you are looking for in your organization, then go to it. But, if you want to push the envelope and stretch for something better, you need to work on overlooking the flaws and quirks that many highly talented people bring to the table. If you don’t, you end up with someone like Taylor Hicks — the safest and most forgettable American Idol winner ever. How hot has his career been lately?
A committee approach to hiring doesn’t always yield the best candidate:
Lots of organizations like to have candidates get interviewed and evaluated by a slew of different managers before everyone weighs in with their opinion. It’s a “safe” talent acquisition approach. American Idol works this way, too, with the judges and nationwide voters all weighing in on who they believe is best. It’s a time-honored approach, of course, but hiring by committee rarely yields the best candidate. For every superstar like Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson, you get a slew of middle-of-the-road winners like Ruben Studdard, Chris Allen, David Cook, and Hicks.
Your company would also be better served by limiting the vetting of candidates to a smaller group of four to five key decision-makers rather than running potential hires through a gauntlet of managers up and down the food chain. I bet you’ll find this approach not only leads to making better decisions about talent, but is less stressful on the candidates and your organization.
You need to ask yourself — do I hire for competence now or for growth potential down the road?
In most seasons, the American Idol winner reflects someone chosen for solid competence right now over someone who may have more upside in the years to come. That’s why last year’s most talented and colorful Idol finalist (Adam Lambert) was passed over for someone with a lot less potential (winner Kris Allen [4]). Other highly talented but less polished Idol candidates, like Chris Daughtry and this year’s Siobham Magnus, seemed to suffer from this, too.
Except in very rare cases, high potential tomorrow is always preferable to solid competence today, but many HR leaders and talent managers don’t agree. Making the safe choice won’t get you in trouble and may help the organization immediately, but going with the high-potential candidate is likely to yield a lot more if you can afford to be patient. In other words, you won’t build superstars taking the safe road, and isn’t building an organization of superstars what it is all about?
Yes, American Idol is all about top talent winning out, but like a lot of things in life, it’s less about finding the very best talent and more about finding someone who is highly talented and acceptable to a large group of constituents. It leads, in the end, to all-too-many vanilla choices, and while that may be acceptable for American Idol, it’s not the optimum way for you to get the very best talent into your organization.
In other words, you need to hire like Simon Cowell. That’s a tougher way to go, but in the end, you’ll have a lot better talent — and bottom-line results — to show for it.
This article comes from Electronic Recruiting Exchange, on May 27, 2010 from John Hollon. Go to http://www.ere.net/2010/05/27/what-Teahr-can-learn-from-american-idol/ to read the whole article.